Butler flashed into the national consciousness on Feb. 1, 2015. With the Seattle Seahawks on New England’s 1-yard line, Butler intercepted a pass with 20 seconds to play to preserve the Patriots’ ...

We caught up with one-hit wonders and former teammates about the Super Bowl's most unlikely, historic performances.

The NFL is all about the next man up. And sometimes, that next man becomes a long-shot winner of the Super Bowl MVP award.

The saga escalated from there, with Butler receiving more suspensions and Riley and the Heat ultimately deciding to make the ...