The couple showed off their matching wedding bands (and black manicures ... You Might Like Winnie Harlow's Nail Pro Found the Perfect Nude for Her Engagement Mani. Now He Wants to Help You ...

Exactly one week after Katie Thurston and Jeff Arcuri said "I do" in a surprise wedding ceremony, the reality TV alum is on the hunt for the perfect wedding band. "Freshly cleaned," Thurston, 34, ...