Caye Caulker isn’t your typical resort-laden getaway ... For that once-in-a-lifetime romantic getaway, consider boutique hotels like Weezie’s Oceanfront Hotel & Garden Cottages.

shops and hotels perched at the northern tip near the Split (the area where Hurricane Hattie allegedly parted Caye Caulker into two halves in 1961), which is now a popular spot for water sports.